How I Got “High-Ticket” Wrong

After my recent musings about how to meet the current market – and whether a high-ticket offer is the right next move – I decided to build one myself.

And I got so stuck.

I took notes. Sketched out ideas. Thought about my ideal client.

I mapped out VIP Days, masterminds, maybe even a retreat… but nothing clicked.

(Spoiler alert: what I discovered next lit a fire under me. So much so that I put together a full training.)

Back to my rabbit hole…

I even turned to my favorite AI tool to brainstorm, and it only got worse.

The results? Hype-y. Unclear. Focused on selling instead of serving.

After spinning my wheels for days, two big realizations finally clicked into place:

1. I was out of alignment with my values.

I make no apologies for charging well for my work – but money isn’t what drives me.

Impact is.

And the more I tried to create a “high-ticket” offer – the kind that centers around pricing and sales language – the more it felt like pushing a boulder uphill… in shoes two sizes too small.

And that’s when it hit me: I don’t want to create a high-ticket offer.

I want to create a High-Impact Program.

That’s not just a different label. It’s a realignment – of values and strategy.

2. I was trying to force one kind of offer – when I actually needed two.

Once I shifted the focus to impact, I figured I’d be off and running. I sat down to design my new signature program…

And I stalled again.

So I looked back at the two biggest turning points in my business:

  • The first was about 5 years in, when I created my first high-ticket offer. That was the year I finally broke six figures.
  • The second was in 2024, when I built a completely different kind of high-impact program – and it finally pushed me past the $200k ceiling where I’d been stuck for way too long.

But they were completely different strategies – and served completely different purposes. 

One was a Catalyst Offer – an upgraded experience that helped my clients get results faster or go deeper than my core programs.

The other was a Core Offer – a fundamental shift in how I worked, charged, and delivered results that changed the entire trajectory of my business.

They were both transformational. But they served completely different purposes – and unlocking both changed everything.

If I’d known how to build both of these styles earlier in my career…

I’m 100% certain I would’ve reached those milestones years sooner.

And the real kicker?

I realized I didn’t need to create another high-impact program right now.

What I needed was to unpack what I’d already built – and help others build the right kind of program for where they are now.

Because when you get this right, it’s not just about a new offer.

It’s about building a business that’s more profitable, more sustainable, and finally feels like it makes sense.

So now? That’s exactly what I’m teaching.

Here are the details.

Mary Cravets

Founder Mary Cravets started Simply Get Clients because she saw small business owners complicating growing their businesses. Or falling victim to the "build it and they will come" myth. So she developed the simple structure to cut through all the noise of social media, "experts", online funnels, advertising and more to focus on the central problem of business owners: getting more clients. And you know what? There is NOT a one-size-fits-all solution.

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *